Tuesday, April 7, 2009

Basal Literacy

Basalized literacy programs are very put together for the teachers and the students. They include planned lessons and activities for every day of the school year. They are leveled stories that start with easier vocabulary and sentences and go up in level as the year goes on. Each unit teaches a different comprehension, discussion, fluency development, writing responses to literature, modeling and guided reading techniques. Each teacher has a copy of a teacher’s addition that spells out and gives direct instructions for the lessons, activities and discussions that should go along with the unit for each day. A good Basal program includes all aspects of literacy. These include: reading, phonics and other skills, strategies, vocabulary, comprehension, literature, content-area study, oral language, writing, and spelling. Most basal programs include selections in grade level textbooks. This means that every book in the program is at the expected grade level. This causes many problems with lower or higher level student who need accommodations such as audio tapes. They also include instruction in skills and strategies. “Teachers use basal reading programs to deliver explicit and systematic instruction that is aligned with state literacy standards” (Tompkins, 341). Many of these skills are learned through workbooks which are included in the programs. The workbooks are also helpful before, during, and after reading. They help to reinforce the lesson and the previous instructions. The basals also include independent reading opportunities. Most programs have many copies of books that are at the levels of the students that they can read on their own. Some times teachers must provide their own books for excelling or lower students. This causes more work for the teacher but the accommodations are helpful to the students. Finally the programs include management plans. These plans are laid out daily and weekly and are unit based.

There are a few roles for the teacher when using basal reading programs. The teacher first and foremost must accommodate for the students that are not at level. This allows all the students to progress at their own rate and learn what they should be learning. Also, the teacher needs to pick and chose what lessons they will use. Most programs provide a lot of lessons and activities. Teachers know their students best and how they learn therefore some things may be skipped while other may be added. The teacher will also lead guided reading, create centers, teach the lessons, and model what is expected of the students. These programs also help teachers. This is because they lay out the lessons and the lessons are aligned with the state literacy standards.

Connecting it back to my experiences in the classroom, I think that I see more benefits then harmful things with basal reading programs. I think they are such a great tool for teachers. Even though they are based on one level they cut the work of the teacher. The basic lesson is planed and then the teacher must accommodate for those rather then starting from scratch. I have seen these programs used in the program and have used them myself. It is amazing how much content they put in each lesson. I like that they provide so many idea but then can not expect you to use all these ideas in a week. They defiantly give ideas for centers in the classroom. This is a great idea for first year teachers. I think that the basal programs really allow the teacher to teach more and prepare a bit less.

Sarah DeBeliso Basalized learning programs

Basalized learning programs have many positive and negative aspects. These are reading programs that are in school districts that are consistent with one reading level. They are reading programs that include all aspects of literacy such as phonics, phonemic awareness, fluency, comprehension, vocabulary, etc. This program involves different books and worksheets used to teach students reading and literacy skills.
As I have read in the Tompkins book and from what I have observed in my classrooms this year and growing up, teachers use these programs to keep on track and used as a guideline of where the students should be. Tompkins does address the need for teachers to work with their colleagues to create various lessons and work with other on different reading levels to bring a variety in the classroom. Some positive ideas that I gathered are that, as mentioned previously, teachers can use this program as a way to test and make sure their students are where they should be along with the district. This is used as a guide to what students are expected to know and where to be. Another quality use of these materials is all of the literacy aspects it brings to the students. These students benefit greatly in learning new vocabulary, following along with tapes, re-reading as to help them with their fluency. My CT uses the questions in the back to guide her own questions for the students to gather their comprehension of the story. Teachers can use this to plan lessons and teach the students. In my opinion it is an easy way to fill time or give to a substitute teacher however, there are many negatives that go along with these positives.
A huge negative aspect that I found in the reading and have experienced in my classroom is that there are so many different reading levels in the class that some students may not be at the level of the program or some may be too high. This is exactly where the idea that Tompkins presented about working with colleagues comes into play. It is necessary for the students learning that they are given reading and literacy material for their level. Working with teachers of higher or lover levels to get ideas of how to differentiate in the classroom is a great idea.
Through my experiences working in the classroom and growing up, I see myself being able to use this material. As we are learning so much about differentiating in the classroom, I would need to be careful of what I used and how I am using it. I would need to make sure it benefits the whole classroom and every individual. I am a little nervous to do this as it will be hard to differentiate the first few years, but as a first year teacher I do see myself gaining a lot of help and knowledge from these materials. I know there are negatives to them, but it gives great guidelines and is a great reference for teachers on what and how to teach. I would even necessarily have to use the books with the students or the worksheets, I would be able to review them myself and figure out what exactly I want to do with them and what different areas I should be teaching. Perhaps when I begin teaching I may find these to not be useful to me, but I don’t see the harm in trying it out for the first year or two and seeing how the program helps or doesn’t benefit my classroom and students.

Monday, April 6, 2009

Basalized Literacy Programs_Allyson LaMarca

In my past few years being in the classroom, I don't think i realized how much many of the Lansing schools relied on basalized literacy programs as the main source of implementing and teaching literacy skills within their classrooms.  I think these literacy programs are used to teach students strategies to be effective readers while making sure to implement ideas that correspond with both the state and national standards.  From my understanding, i feel that it is a program used to expose all the students in the same schools and districts to the same literature.  However, I do understand what Tompkins was saying about how many teachers want more authentic material and how the programs often focus on controlled vocabulary.  In fact, these programs are in a sense are mass produced trying to give each student the same literacy experiences, however, with the different learning styles, interests and academic abilities, I dont think it is sufficient to rely on one literacy system that treats all students the same way.  Two of the three teachers I have been with during my teaching program were older teachers who have been teaching for 30 years and they often disregarded much of the material in the programs and found other activities that met the requirements but catered to their students specifically.  They find this programs to be too tedious to follow and often make their lessons less authentic and effective.  Having so much experience behind them, it is feasible for them to come up with alternative methods to get their students to acquire these skills and reading strategies.   Although I have experienced some of the negative sides of this type of program, for me, basal reading programs are great because they lay out the lessons for you and for a beginning teacher, it is nice to have specific guidelines on how to teach something. Also, because basal readings reflect behaviorism, a teacher centered theory where teachers provide direct instruction through lessons and materials, newer teachers are given a structure and manner in which to teach the students and this type of direct instruction is really the teaching style, that at least I as a new teacher, feel most comfortable with. I also think that these types of programs have  a plithera of resources such as workbooks, overheads, reading kits, and supplemental books so that the students have various resources to rely on for added reinforcement.  I feel that this type of programs can really evolve into something useful, and like anything else, with trial and error and feedback, I think that these programs can eventually get to be a program that helps implement literacy strategies, follow the state guidelines as well as try to cater to the individual needs of classrooms and their students.  I really feel that I have a conflicted opinion on these programs because i think that they are essential to classrooms, however, should not be the primary literary resources and are really most effective when paired with other activities and teaching styles.  Like all subjects, I believe that variety and reinforcements are essential in getting students to acquire the strategies needed to be able to retain information, interpret it and use it to be successful in their learning environment. As for questions about this type of program, i want to know the process that these companies go through to figure out what is the most effective literature to present to all the students in the district and what vocabulary they think is the most essential for students to learn.