Basalized learning programs have many positive and negative aspects. These are reading programs that are in school districts that are consistent with one reading level. They are reading programs that include all aspects of literacy such as phonics, phonemic awareness, fluency, comprehension, vocabulary, etc. This program involves different books and worksheets used to teach students reading and literacy skills.
As I have read in the Tompkins book and from what I have observed in my classrooms this year and growing up, teachers use these programs to keep on track and used as a guideline of where the students should be. Tompkins does address the need for teachers to work with their colleagues to create various lessons and work with other on different reading levels to bring a variety in the classroom. Some positive ideas that I gathered are that, as mentioned previously, teachers can use this program as a way to test and make sure their students are where they should be along with the district. This is used as a guide to what students are expected to know and where to be. Another quality use of these materials is all of the literacy aspects it brings to the students. These students benefit greatly in learning new vocabulary, following along with tapes, re-reading as to help them with their fluency. My CT uses the questions in the back to guide her own questions for the students to gather their comprehension of the story. Teachers can use this to plan lessons and teach the students. In my opinion it is an easy way to fill time or give to a substitute teacher however, there are many negatives that go along with these positives.
A huge negative aspect that I found in the reading and have experienced in my classroom is that there are so many different reading levels in the class that some students may not be at the level of the program or some may be too high. This is exactly where the idea that Tompkins presented about working with colleagues comes into play. It is necessary for the students learning that they are given reading and literacy material for their level. Working with teachers of higher or lover levels to get ideas of how to differentiate in the classroom is a great idea.
Through my experiences working in the classroom and growing up, I see myself being able to use this material. As we are learning so much about differentiating in the classroom, I would need to be careful of what I used and how I am using it. I would need to make sure it benefits the whole classroom and every individual. I am a little nervous to do this as it will be hard to differentiate the first few years, but as a first year teacher I do see myself gaining a lot of help and knowledge from these materials. I know there are negatives to them, but it gives great guidelines and is a great reference for teachers on what and how to teach. I would even necessarily have to use the books with the students or the worksheets, I would be able to review them myself and figure out what exactly I want to do with them and what different areas I should be teaching. Perhaps when I begin teaching I may find these to not be useful to me, but I don’t see the harm in trying it out for the first year or two and seeing how the program helps or doesn’t benefit my classroom and students.
Tuesday, April 7, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment