Tuesday, January 20, 2009

LaMarca_Blog#1

The readings today touched on the various types of talks one could see in a classroom. Particularly, in my 5th grade classroom, I often see my students and the teacher engaging in IRE conversations where the teacher is constantly prompting the students with questions in order to keep the conversation moving and get meaning out the subject they are discussing. I do believe that IREs are important at a younger age because it shows students what types of questions and instances they should be thinking of when they are looking at the text. By the teacher asking questions or prompting the students to look further into what they are saying, the students is realizing the responsibilities they have to the class at that time, to look at a text or subject and dig deep to find meaning in order to comprehend it. I also believe the students by listening to what other students have to say on a given topic, may trigger his/her peers to understand the material being presented to them in a reading. Sometime it takes alternative perspectives and interpretations of one or more ideas in order for a student to fully comprehend its meaning. I have quite a few students in my classroom who do not participate in group discussions and I find that both myself and the teacher encourage them by specifically asking them a question or two in the midst of the discussion portion of class. At this point, they have heard the responses and opinions from a few students, thereby, there are given examples of the types of answers expected. I have not seen much response centered reading within this 5th grade classroom, however, when I was placed in a 2nd grade classroom this year, I was given the opportunity to run small reading groups and this type of discussion came in handy. I dont think I realized the importance of illustrations to children until I saw the impressions it had on these students. I primarily thought illustrations primarily served as an aesthetic purpose, however, by focusing on the illustrations and looking at the environment and characters being presented, the students are given the chance to interpret the text more thoroughly through the illustrations. I had a quite a few ELLs in this classroom, and regardless of the language one speaks natively, pictures speak a thousand words, so although these students were not getting much from the text, they were able to make up what they missed from the text by looking at the pictures. Lastly, I found Wheeler and Swords article to be very insightful while discussing the various dialects students are often taught at home and therefore, use in the school setting. Because most of my experience with students has been in the Lansing school district, which has a lot of variety in ethniticty and cultural groups, I have heard a wider variety of dialects spoken my students. I often find myself questioning how to react to this type of verbal communication because the student is using to talking in a particular way due to the environment they are exposed to at home, however, in school, students are taught to speak verbally following the "rules of grammar". When students have been speaking one way for 7 or 8 years, are we as teachers supposed to correct their speech?

2 comments:

  1. Allyson, you bring up a great question. I often think the same thing. You can not tell a child that the way they speak is wrong just because it is different to you and how you were raised. I am not sure what I'd do in the situation. I think I'd have to see the situation and classroom environment. This is a great thing to think about and we could also bring this up in the discussion board to see what our peers would say. I also liked your thoughts about illustrations. I have only ever worked with children no older than 9. The illustrations to them are what helps get them through the reading. It is very helpful for them to have. If they aren't sure of a word they will look at the picture and see if anything they notice makes sense in the reading where they are stuck. It is very important for them to have pictures at this age. The pictures also keep them excited about the readings. I'm not sure when the pictures stop, I would think maybe 3rd or 4th grade? I think you had a great observation when you helped out in the 2nd grade classroom!

    ReplyDelete
  2. I like the point you make about the importance of IREs used with different grade levels. I think this connects well with our classroom discussion about discussion. Its almost as if IRE will dwindle and discussion will excel as students learn what is expected of them and classroom management progresses. Allyson, I see this importance of illustrations all the time in my first grade classroom. We are always doing a picture walk through first or asking the students to look at the picture if they do not know a word. And IRE is important when it comes to reading groups in younger classrooms. This is because the students are just learning comprehension, title, author, beginning, middle, end, etc. So the easiest way to see if they grasp these concepts is by prompting them with questions to answer. The topic of correction student’s speech falls hand in hand with what I have been discussing with my ENG 302 class. We have discussed dialect and grammar differences among groups for the past couple of classes. I have came to the conclusion (well at least for now) that what we are taught in school is important due to the fact that it is expected of use to learn “proper English” in order to stay away from the stereotype of being dumb or stupid. There is a time or a place I guess is what I am trying to say. It’s not that one way is better then the other it is just that we need to learn proper grammar to achieve our goals. On that note I think that Obama’s speech patterns and dialect will help society become more accepting of the African American dialect due to the power he holds in our country.

    ReplyDelete